Department of Internal Medicine,
Division of Gastroenterology, Nippon Medical School, Tokyo, Japan
OBJECTIVE: Studies suggest that synbiotic therapy could
prove more effective in the treatment of ulcerative colitis (UC) than therapies
limited to probiotics or prebiotics. This study compared the effect of each of
these therapies in the treatment of UC. METHODS: One hundred twenty outpatients
with UC were randomly sorted into three groups of 40 patients each for
probiotic, prebiotic, or synbiotic therapy. The probiotic group ingested one
daily capsule consisting of Bifidobacterium longum 2 x 10(9) colony-forming
units and the prebiotic group ingested daily 8.0-g doses of psyllium. The
synbiotic group underwent both treatments. All patients completed Inflammatory
Bowel Disease Questionnaires (IBDQs) at the onset of the trial, at the 2-wk
midpoint, and at the 4-wk end of the trial. Blood variables were also evaluated
in a subset of 32 patients randomly selected from all groups and values were
compared with IBDQ scores. RESULTS: Thirty-one patients in the probiotic group,
31 in the prebiotic group, and 32 in the synbiotic group qualified for analyses.
The remaining 26 patients had incomplete questionnaires. Total IBDQ scores
improved within groups by the end of the trial (probiotics 162 to 169, NS;
prebiotics 174 to 182, NS; synbiotics 168 to 176, P = 0.03). Individual scores
improved as follows: probiotics, emotional function (P = 0.03); prebiotics,
bowel function (P = 0.04); and synbiotics, systemic and social functions (P =
0.008 and P = 0.02). C-reactive protein decreased significantly only with
synbiotic therapy (from 0.59 to 0.14 mg/dL, P = 0.04). There were no adverse
events. CONCLUSION: Patients with UC on synbiotic therapy experienced greater
quality-of-life changes than patients on probiotic or prebiotic treatment. These
data suggest that synbiotic therapy may have a synergistic effect in the
treatment of UC.